What Going Pro on PR Actually Cost
How much does a PR firm cost? We just signed with one, and that was the hardest number to find when we went looking. We’re one month in, so I can’t tell you whether it worked. What I can tell you is why we did it, how we picked a firm, and what it actually costs a small brand.
Why PR, and why now
Our biggest challenge is trust. We like to think we’re good, trustworthy people, but our products are things customers use in their most intimate, sensitive moments. We take that seriously. It’s also completely reasonable, and honestly prudent, for people to make an e-commerce brand earn their trust. Nobody wants to be the guinea pig for a new brand, especially when a bad outcome could be costly and miserable.
So how do you start building that? We landed on three things:
- A great first impression. A well-designed site with professional images. (Our v1 site taught us that the hard way, and product photography deserves its own post soon.)
- Reviews from existing customers. An independent perspective for new people who don’t know us yet.
- Articles in respected publications. This is where PR comes in.
The “why now” ties back to the goal we’ve been writing about for the last few weeks: moving away from local markets and leaning into wholesale and direct-to-consumer. (Here’s what has to be true before we can fully do that.) We can’t build that credibility alone. It’s much more efficient to rely on people who already have the connections and a practiced, strategic approach to pitching a brand.
How we picked a firm
We talked to three or four firms. We weighed experience, how their clients in our niche had done, and whether they had a logical strategic roadmap. I won’t call anyone out by name, but a couple of them came across less as PR experts and more as bullshit artists, and not the good kind.
That last point ended up deciding it. One firm made us feel like they actually understood our brand vision, and they had the credentials and the enthusiasm to take it on. When you’re handing someone your story, that matters more than any line on a pricing sheet.
How much does a PR firm cost?
There isn’t one number. There are three layers.
The fixed fee. Every firm we talked to landed somewhere between $2,000 and $4,000 a month, on an initial three-month contract. That works out to somewhere around $6,000 to $12,000 for the first stretch, before anything else. The fixed fee includes a minimum of 10 pitches a month to outlets. You can pay more for a more aggressive approach, and some firms also offer connections into wholesale opportunities. We started with the initial package and haven’t added the wholesale piece, though we’re considering it for next year.
The variable costs. Some outlets, definitely not all, are pay-to-play. If you want a spot on a show, that probably costs more. We haven’t been pitched anything like that yet, but it wouldn’t shock me if Chrissy and I end up having that conversation. Most outlets and writers will also want samples so they can give an honest account of the product. Some will be sample sachets, and some will be full-sized products, shipping included.
The affiliate program. This isn’t exclusively PR, but it’s the same kind of downstream cost, so I’m including it. We had an initial sign-up cost of about $500, then around $100 a month to stay in the program. On each qualified sale we pay a percentage to the referrer and 2% to the program itself. All in, that can take roughly 7 to 12% out of the margin on DTC sales.
We’re betting we’ll make that back through volume. It’s a bet, and I’d rather say so plainly than pretend I know how it turns out.
What we expected, and where we are
Honestly, we expect a little bit of everything: features, press, sales, and other people telling our story for us. Right now we’re in month one, which means framing the pitch and our brand positioning, building the outlet list, starting outreach, and waiting.
It’s too soon to tell how effective any of it is. We’re excited to be starting, and we believe it’s the right next step for where we are today.
What we’re hoping for
The practical hope is that it pays off during this holiday season, and that it gives us something to point to when we pitch other businesses at AmericasMart in January.
The less practical hope is more selfish. I’d love to be able to point to Allure, Vogue, WebMD, or Cosmopolitan and say, “look at us. We belong in these outlets like any other legitimate brand.” That would do double duty: social proof for new customers, and a boost to our own confidence that we won’t be tied down to being a local market staple forever.
I’ll write the follow-up once there’s something to report, good or bad. Handing our story to someone else to tell is a whole other thing, and it’s the next post.